DICE PACKS BUNDLE
  1. #1

    Would you suggest Fantasy Grounds to me?

    Hello everyone,

    I've played around with the FG demos (various versions) here and there, but have yet to take the plunge and purchase it. I was wondering if the community here could help me decide if it is right for me.

    I know we can't predict the future. I'm just asking for your thoughts, speculation and advice.

    I notice that buyers of FGI got FGII upgrade for free. Is this correct or did I hear this wrong? If I buy FGII, would I be eligible for a free FGIII upgrade, when and if it comes? Or too early to say? What about a reduced price upgrade path?

    I appreciate the breadth of fan-made rulesets that exist. My main interest at this point is in playing D&D 4th edition. I'm aware of the 4e ruleset being developed right now which is sure to improve more and more over time. however, I am a little concerned that the 4e player base will dry up once WotC launches their shiny new 3D virtual tabletop sometime in 2009. Should I be worried?

    What is known about upcoming FG feature additions? Smiteworks seems pretty good about updating their product, but I can't find any changelogs of past versions, or a roadmap of upcoming features. Knowing these things could definitely help sway me.

    Those are the big issues that come to mind. I wouldn't mind hearing your arguments as to why I should use FG over MapTool, either.

    Thanks a lot everyone!

  2. #2
    Doswelk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Surrey, UK
    Posts
    2,690
    Hi Zulithe!

    I'll try and answer some of these questions I am sure others are more qualified than me but here we go!

    Quote Originally Posted by Zulithe
    I notice that buyers of FGI got FGII upgrade for free. Is this correct or did I hear this wrong? If I buy FGII, would I be eligible for a free FGIII upgrade, when and if it comes? Or too early to say? What about a reduced price upgrade path?
    FG1 users did get an upgrade to FGII for free, as to FGIII well no-one knows about that yet! (except maybe Smiteworks)

    Quote Originally Posted by Zulithe
    I appreciate the breadth of fan-made rulesets that exist. My main interest at this point is in playing D&D 4th edition. I'm aware of the 4e ruleset being developed right now which is sure to improve more and more over time. however, I am a little concerned that the 4e player base will dry up once WotC launches their shiny new 3D virtual tabletop sometime in 2009. Should I be worried?
    Well from what I gather WotC will require a monthly subscription, FGII does not, WotC version will have all the rulebooks (you have bought) built in FGII does not but there are scripts on the FUM site (along with the 4e ruleset), so time will tell

    Personally as I do not play D&D anymore I am biased to FGII, but there is quite a large number of FGII 4e D&D'ers so I think FGII is safe.

    Quote Originally Posted by Zulithe
    What is known about upcoming FG feature additions? Smiteworks seems pretty good about updating their product, but I can't find any changelogs of past versions, or a roadmap of upcoming features. Knowing these things could definitely help sway me.
    There is a change list inside FGII (which is not much help if yo do not have it yet!), but I seem to recall that somewhere on this site whenever a patch is pushed out they list the changes there.

    Quote Originally Posted by Zulithe
    Those are the big issues that come to mind. I wouldn't mind hearing your arguments as to why I should use FG over MapTool, either.
    Again I am not the best person to answer that as my useage of Maptools was only once and I could not get on with it (that was my lack of time with it not the tool itself), I'm too attached to FGII it seems!

    Quote Originally Posted by Zulithe
    Thanks a lot everyone!
    Hope I was some help....
    My players just defeated an army, had a dogfight with aliens, machine-gunned the zombies, stormed the tower, became Legendary and died heroically

    Yours are still on combat round 6

    Get Savage
    Ultimate License Holder.
    First GM to post a game for the original FG Con!

  3. #3
    Quote Originally Posted by Zulithe
    Smiteworks seems pretty good about updating their product, but I can't find any changelogs of past versions,
    If you search the House of Healing forum on this site for "update available", you will find several posts made by the developers with changelogs for released versions.

    Quote Originally Posted by Zulithe
    I wouldn't mind hearing your arguments as to why I should use FG over MapTool, either.
    If you don't mind using VoIP chat and external parafernalia like character sheets and such, I guess MapTool could suit your needs for simple online AD&D interaction as well. I don't know MapTool, but from what I see online, it's a program to share maps with some extra die functionality built in.
    FG is more than that, it has character sheet (I always like when me and the players see the same character sheet) and ruleset info in there as well (both adaptable by the community!), along with a combat tracker which is nice for a DM. Also, FG has pretty nice map tools, like markers where you can link story info to certain area's of the map. FG offers ways to "organize" your adventure as a DM, which I need very much *grin*

    Plus, FG looks nice (hey, to me that's important, too!)

  4. #4
    I once read an interview somewhere with... Ged... I believe... one of the Smiteworks fellows, at any rate. One of the questions was what sets FG2 apart from other VTs. He said he wanted to make a VT that didn't look like a windows application. So as silly as it might sound at first that "FG looks nice," I think this is one of its most important features. It's all about immersion. FG makes players feel like they're at a TABLETOP, not some sort of image-sharing software.

    Also, about the 4e thing, I just want to mention that even if WotC steals a number of 4e players frmo FG (I doubt it'll have a huge impact, but IF), the 4e rulesets already have more features than the built-in 3.5 ruleset, so no worries about that ruleset being useable or available.

  5. #5

    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Arkansas
    Posts
    7,417
    Most of the other questions were covered so I give you my thoughts on this one.
    Quote Originally Posted by Zulithe
    Those are the big issues that come to mind. I wouldn't mind hearing your arguments as to why I should use FG over MapTool, either.
    This is a good question. I like the developer of MapTools very much. Trever is responsive and must be a god with Java to get a graphical app like MapTool to run so fast and trouble free. It's his personal baby and he puts in tons of effort.

    So why do I play RPGs with FG? I use FG because I think it is better rounded for RPG play. As Zubulis mentioned the emphasis is different between the two programs. MapTool - like the name suggests - is all about the *map* and it does that very well. It displays them, allows you to do all sorts of maps of the fly, and has great LOS, lighting and other nifty features. I would use MapTools for playing a board game like Space Hulk online.

    FG on the other hand is about RPGs - the core of the application is around the character sheet, Monsters/NPCs and the combat tracker. Its map features are not as awesome but resemble a battlemap at a table - sparse but adequate. It does a great job of *feeling* like you are around a table playing an RPG. The dice add to this feeling. Because Smitworks simulated a table in a face to face game it interface is very easy to understand for anyone who has played in a face to face game. This gives it an easier learning curve than most other VTT apps, including MapTool.

    Basically, I think MapTool is a better app if you want to focus you game around the game map. On the other hand, I think FG is better if you want to play an RPG online with a similar feel to a face to face game. That's my 2 cents.
    Last edited by Griogre; December 11th, 2008 at 20:02.

  6. #6
    Thanks for your replies everyone!

    Doswell: I'd say you were helpful, yes! I'll try to find those changelogs that you said are in threads... thanks.

    zabulus: ahh, houses of healing. gotcha! VoIP software is useful, and I think a lot of groups would insist on using it these days. I know that when I play WoW it is almost essential. It speeds things up so well. I'm sure it would do wonders for a VTT as well.

    EugeneZ: Well I can't argue there, it certainly is pretty.

    Grigore: Sounds like a fair assessment to me. I agree that maptool excells as an easy-to-use map CREATION program, and I hope the developer focuses more on that strength in the future and expands on it. It doesn't have the nice built-in reference materials or character sheets, and from a usability pov is probably trailing FG somewhat.

  7. #7
    Xorn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Helena, MT
    Posts
    1,077
    Regarding the 4E_JPG ruleset, if the DDi VT takes care of half what it does, then the DDi VT will be a good value. Of course it'll still only be doing half of what 4E_JPG does. Ruleset support for 4E is there already (and quite a few other systems).

    I agree whole-heartedly with Griogre, too. MapTool has a very powerful set of tools for working with the map (BattlegroundsRPG is no slouch), but for the "complete" virtual tabletop experience, I get that from FG2.

    Those are the reasons I would get FG2. For a sneak-peak of the 4E_JPG ruleset there's a link to a tutorial in my sig, but there have been a lot of new things added since I made it.
    "We all take our risks, here in the dungeon." --Bargle
    Watch For Falling Meteors (Twitch.tv) Wednesday @ 7:00 PM Mountain - 5E World of Mystara
    Ultimate License DM
    Watch for Falling Meteors (YouTube Playlist)
    Xorn's 5E @ FG Tutorials (YouTube Playlist)

  8. #8
    I don't have much to add to those very good comments, only this:

    I think the price for FG is very reasonable and I after playing 7 sessions online, I got my moneys worth. It's well invested money.
    So if you think that you'll use FG at least a couple of times, maybe host a game yourself, then just give it a go. If Insider really suits you better, you can still switch over. If it ever goes online, that is! :-)

  9. #9
    I would suggest it to you. Buy the full version!

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
5E Character Create Playlist

Log in

Log in